PoliceOracle.com

Police Hit Back At 'Leniency' Accusations

Police Hit Back At 'Leniency' Accusations

Cambridgeshire ACC; 'Of course the statistics look shocking - because they are bare figures being viewed in isolation'.

Date - 23rd September 2009
Courtesy of - Cambridgeshire Police


Cambridgeshire police today hit back at widespread accusations of leniency with criminals - calling on critics to examine the facts behind the figures before opening fire.

The force was responding to criticism by politicians, a children's charity and a taxpayers' group who had condemned it for its use of cautions and final warnings for offenders, revealed in response to a media request under the Freedom of Information Act.

"Of course the statistics look shocking - because they are bare figures being viewed in isolation," said Deputy Chief Constable, John Feavyour.

"What they don't tell anyone, and what we have to be very careful about when going into any detail, is the circumstances behind many of the sexual offences in particular.

"They involve victims and offenders who are both under the legal age for sexual activity. For example, a girl under 16 cannot legally give consent for sexual intercourse. That means that if two 15-year-olds have sex by mutual consent, there is an offence of rape.

"All of these sorts of facts are carefully considered by police and prosecutors in consultation with the victim and parents or guardians.

"The seriousness of the offence is also explained to the offender before a decision is made.

"Clearly, no-one wants to impose the potential trauma of a court appearance on young people who will probably never offend in the same way again, and have already learned their lesson in more ways than one.

"The same considerations also apply to other types of offences involving adults. Have they offended before, are they likely to do so again - and how serious is the offence? What is not always realised is that offences have to be categorised under certain headings for the purpose of recording statistics.

"So while someone may be accused of assault, perhaps on a police officer, it may be relatively minor, or the victim may not be willing to make a complaint - and that is when a caution is often used. There is also a large element of commonsense involved.

"But we are not being soft on criminals. Those who are so quick to criticise the police need to ask more questions first rather than using bare statistics to beat the service with.

"And let us, once and for all, dispel the myth that issuing a caution is tantamount to letting people go with a ticking off. It is a complex, strict and lengthy process which involves an admission of guilt and goes on an individual's record.

"We will continue to use them where they are appropriate - both for the sake of the victim and the offender, and, in particular, where they are young people who are just beginning to learn that life holds some hard lessons."

 

 

Do you have an interesting news story? Contact the newsdesk on 01737 648 432
or alternatively get in touch via the contact form.

Categories and Tags

Anonymous Anonymous says...